DOJ Criminal Division chief says open source smart contract devs not criminally liable without intent
Justice Department (DOJ) Criminal Division head Matthew Galeotti declared that writing code without criminal intent does not constitute a crime, providing crypto developers and smart contract creators with clearer boundaries on criminal liability.
During remarks at the American Innovation Project Summit on Aug. 21, Galeotti stated:
“Our view is that merely writing code without ill intent is not a crime. Innovating new ways for the economy to store and transmit value and create wealth without ill intent is not a crime.”
The comments represent the Justice Department’s most explicit guidance yet on developer responsibility in the digital asset ecosystem.
Developer liability limits
The Criminal Division addressed industry concerns about holding smart contract developers criminally liable for operating unlicensed money transmitting businesses.
Galeotti stressed that developers contributing code to open source projects without specific criminal intent face no liability for aiding and abetting violations.
He explained:
“If a developer merely contributes code to an open source project without the specific intent to assist criminal conduct, aid or abet a particular crime, or join a criminal conspiracy, he or she is not criminally liable.”
Both aiding and abetting charges and conspiracy prosecutions require prosecutors to prove specific intent, establishing a higher evidentiary standard for developer cases.
The guidance directly responds to defense counsel presentations raising concerns about criminal liability for smart contract developers and code publishers not otherwise involved in peer-to-peer transactions.
The Criminal Division acknowledged these as “complex questions of law and fact” requiring rigorous case-by-case evaluation.
Unlicensed money transmission protections
For unlicensed money transmission charges under 18 USC 1960, the department will not prosecute regulatory violations absent evidence that defendants knew specific legal requirements and willfully violated them.
Galeotti provided specific protections for truly decentralized software that automates peer-to-peer transactions without third-party custody or control over user assets, stating:
“Where the evidence shows that software is truly decentralized and solely automates peer-to-peer transactions, and where a third party does not have custody and control over user assets, new 1960(b)(1)(C) charges against a third party will not be approved.”
The guidance considers regulatory guidance suggesting that non-custodial crypto software does not constitute unlicensed money transmission.
Further, Galeotti established clear principles distinguishing between legitimate development and criminal conduct.
Developers of neutral tools with no criminal intent should not be held responsible for third-party misuse of their creations. When third parties violate criminal law using developer tools, prosecutors should target the misusing party rather than well-intentioned creators.
The DOJ official described the department’s technology-neutral approach, which treats digital asset crimes identically to traditional financial violations while protecting lawful innovation from regulatory overreach.
The post DOJ Criminal Division chief says open source smart contract devs not criminally liable without intent appeared first on CryptoSlate.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
The Case for XRP: How the First Spot XRP ETF Catalyzes Institutional Adoption and Long-Term Value Creation
- SEC's August 2025 ruling confirms XRP is not a security in secondary markets, resolving a decade-long dispute with Ripple. - Seven major asset managers submitted revised XRP ETF applications, with potential $5-8B institutional inflows driving price targets of $10-$15. - XRP's 3-5 second settlement speed and 70% lower cross-border payment costs position it as a superior bridge asset compared to Bitcoin and Ethereum. - Regulatory clarity and RippleNet's 90+ market adoption create a durable moat despite ris

Bitcoin News Today: Blockchain Bolsters Trust, Bitcoin Seeks a Place in the Philippines' Future
- Philippines launches blockchain document verification via Polygon to combat forgery and enhance public fund accountability. - DBM's system uses cryptographic hashes for real-time validation, developed with local firm Bayanichain. - House Bill 421 proposes 10,000 BTC strategic reserve over 20 years, aiming to diversify national assets with Bitcoin. - Dual initiatives reflect government's push for digital governance and economic resilience through decentralized technologies.

DOGE Price Prediction for August 27, 2025: Is Now the Time to Ride the Meme Coin Resurgence?
- Dogecoin (DOGE) forms a symmetrical triangle pattern near $0.22–$0.25, with potential for a breakout toward $0.28 or a drop to $0.19. - Institutional whale activity and a Binance transaction suggest growing confidence, while the v1.14.8 upgrade and Tesla/AMC partnerships enhance utility. - The Maxi Doge ($MAXI) ecosystem, with 1000x leverage and cross-chain plans, boosts meme culture but risks diverting attention from DOGE. - Overbought sentiment (Fear & Greed Index at 74) and an 80% ETF approval probabi

Strategic Public-Private Partnerships: Unlocking Africa's Digital Inclusion and Telecom Growth
- Africa's digital transformation accelerates through public-private partnerships (PPPs), bridging the 60% internet access gap via open-source platforms like MOSIP. - Modular systems (e.g., Ghana's GIP, Uganda's UGHub) reduce costs by 30-40%, enabling cross-border interoperability aligned with AU's 2030 digital strategy. - Telecom leaders like MTN and Safaricom demonstrate scalable returns, with M-Pesa serving 50M users and MTN's stock rising 22% in 2025. - Global initiatives (50-in-5, UPI adoption) and Af

Trending news
MoreCrypto prices
More








