Trump's Logo Push Turns Cracker Barrel's Stock Around

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store Inc. faced a significant public backlash following the release of a redesigned logo, which led to a sharp decline in its stock price and market value. The new logo removed the iconic image of "Uncle Herschel," a character central to the brand’s identity for over five decades. The change, part of a broader rebranding effort under CEO Julie Felss Masino, was met with swift criticism, particularly from conservative voices and social media users, who described it as "generic" and accused the company of abandoning its heritage. Shares of Cracker Barrel dropped as much as 15% in early trading after the logo was unveiled on August 19, eroding nearly $200 million from its market value.

The backlash intensified as prominent figures, including former U.S. President Donald Trump, publicly criticized the rebrand. In a post on Truth Social, Trump called the change a mistake and urged the company to revert to its original logo. His intervention appeared to influence the company’s decision, as Cracker Barrel announced on August 26 that it would abandon the new design and return to its classic logo. In a statement, the company said it had "listened" to customers and confirmed that "Uncle Herschel" would remain a key part of its brand, appearing on menus, signage, and in-store displays.

The reversal had an immediate positive impact on the stock, with shares rising more than 8% on Wednesday, August 27. The company’s decision to reverse course was praised by Trump, who congratulated Cracker Barrel and expressed hope that the brand would "make your customers happy again." The stock had already rebounded somewhat on Tuesday, closing up over 6% after the initial announcement of the logo change reversal.

Marketing experts and industry observers noted the rare phenomenon of a company’s stock price being so directly affected by a rebranding decision. Kevin Dahlstrom, a former chief marketing officer in the financial sector, described the move as a "fiasco," emphasizing the importance of preserving a brand identity that customers feel emotionally connected to. The incident underscores the risks associated with brand overhauls, especially for long-established chains with strong cultural associations.

Cracker Barrel’s rebranding effort had aimed to modernize the company’s image through updated menu offerings and store designs. However, the removal of "Uncle Herschel" from the logo was seen by many as a misstep that alienated a core segment of the brand’s customer base. The company now faces the challenge of balancing innovation with the preservation of its heritage, as it continues to evolve its brand identity while maintaining the nostalgic appeal that has defined it for over 50 years.

The episode also highlights the increasing influence of political and social media figures in shaping public perception and corporate decisions. Trump’s involvement in the issue, from calling the change a mistake to congratulating the company on its reversal, demonstrates how public opinion can play a decisive role in high-profile business decisions. As Cracker Barrel moves forward, it will need to carefully navigate the expectations of both its customers and its investors, ensuring that its brand remains relevant without losing sight of its roots.

Source: