Columbia Business professor casts doubt on tokenized bank deposits
Banks and financial institutions have started experimenting with tokenized bank deposits, bank balances recorded on a blockchain, but the technology is doomed to lose out to stablecoins, according to Omid Malekan, an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School.
Overcollateralized stablecoin issuers, who must maintain 1:1 cash or short-term cash equivalent reserves to back their tokens, are safer from a liability perspective than the fractional reserve banks that would issue tokenized bank deposits, Malekan said.
Stablecoins are also composable, meaning they can be transferred across the crypto ecosystem and used in various applications, unlike tokenized deposits, which are permissioned, have know-your-customer (KYC) controls, and have restricted functionality.
Tokenized bank deposits are like a “checking account where you could only write checks to other customers of the same bank,” Malekan continued. He added:
“What’s the point? Such a token can’t be used for most activities. It’s useless for cross-border payments, can’t serve the unbanked, doesn’t offer composability or atomic swaps with other assets, and can’t be used in decentralized finance (DeFi).”
The tokenized real-world asset (RWA) sector, physical or financial assets tokenized on a blockchain, which includes fiat currencies, real estate, equities, bonds, commodities, art, and collectibles, is projected to swell to $2 trillion by 2028, according to the Standard Chartered bank.
Related: BNY explores tokenized deposits to power $2.5T daily payment network: Bloomberg
Stablecoin issuers will share yield one way or another
Tokenized bank deposits must also compete with yield-bearing stablecoins or stablecoin issuers that find ways of circumventing the yield prohibition in the GENIUS stablecoin Act, passing on the yield in the form of various customer rewards, Malekan argued.
The banking lobby has pushed back against yield-bearing stablecoins over fears that stablecoin issuers sharing interest with customers would erode the banking industry’s market share.
The current average yield offered on a savings account at a retail bank in the US or the UK is well under 1%, making anything above that attractive to customers.
The resistance to yield-bearing stablecoins from the banking lobby drew criticism from New York University professor Austin Campbell, who accused the banking industry of using political pressure to protect its financial interests at the cost of retail customers.
Magazine: Can Robinhood or Kraken’s tokenized stocks ever be truly decentralized?
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
Bitcoin News Update: Analyst Highlights How MSTR's Convertible Bonds Prevent Forced Bitcoin Sales
- MSTR's convertible debt structure allows debt repayment via cash, stock, or both, avoiding Bitcoin sales during market downturns. - The company raised €350M through a 10% dividend-bearing euro-denominated preferred stock offering to fund Bitcoin purchases. - Q3 results showed $3.9B operating income from Bitcoin gains, driving a 7.6% stock surge to $273.68 post-earnings. - Risks persist if Bitcoin fails to rally in 2028, potentially forcing partial liquidation amid $1.01B 2027 debt obligations. - MSTR hol

Solana News Today: Solana ETFs Surpass Bitcoin as Staking Returns Attract Institutional Investments
- U.S. spot Solana ETFs (BSOL/GSOL) attracted $199M in 4 days, outperforming Bitcoin/Ethereum ETF outflows. - 7% staking yields drive institutional inflows as investors rotate capital from major crypto assets. - Despite ETF success, SOL price fell below key support levels, raising concerns about $120 price floor. - Strategic staking and treasury purchases boosted Solana's institutional appeal, with $397M in staked assets. - Market remains cautious as ETF competition intensifies, with Bitwise's BSOL outpaci

Bitcoin News Today: Bitcoin’s Fourth Quarter Surge: Impact of Trade Disputes, Stronger Dollar, and Evolving Global Economic Strategies
- Bitcoin fell nearly 15% in October 2024, its worst quarterly start since 2022, driven by U.S.-China trade tensions, dollar strength, and macroeconomic caution. - A 100% U.S. tariff on Chinese imports and Fed rate-cut delays exacerbated selloffs, triggering $1.3B in liquidations during a flash crash below $103,000. - Key support levels at $107,000 and $101,150 face retests as traders warn of further declines, with market cap dropping below $3.6T amid fragile liquidity. - Wintermute denied Binance lawsuit

BNB News Today: AI and Blockchain Unite to Transform the Industry Through Decentralized Innovations
- ChainOpera, an AI-powered blockchain project, raised $40M+ in funding to expand decentralized infrastructure, highlighting growing investor confidence in AI-blockchain convergence. - FedEx partners with ServiceNow to implement AI-driven supply chain analytics, aiming to boost operational efficiency through real-time disruption prediction and automation. - BNB Chain emerges as an AI innovation hub with Avalon Labs' AI-MaaS marketplace and AEON's autonomous payment SDK, enabling decentralized AI model depl

